Polk City's Premier Cheesecake Bakery

Every Slice Delivers the Moment You've Been Waiting For

Handcrafted from scratch, baked to order, and finished with the kind of care that turns a simple dessert into an occasion. No shortcuts. No compromises. Just cheesecake that tastes like it was made for you.

Place Your Order Explore Flavors
100% Made from Scratch
To Order Freshly Baked
Polk City Locally Made
Beautiful handcrafted cheesecake with fresh berry topping
Handcrafted with care
Locally Owned & Operated
Made Fresh — Not Frozen
Quality Ingredients, Every Time
Custom Orders Welcome
Our Selection

Flavors That Make Every Occasion Unforgettable

From timeless classics to bold, signature creations — every cheesecake is handcrafted in small batches using premium ingredients and tested recipes that deliver consistent, exceptional results.

Classic New York style cheesecake with golden crust

Classic New York

Dense, velvety, and unmistakably rich — the benchmark every cheesecake is measured against. A graham cracker crust meets a cloud-like interior.

Cheesecake topped with fresh mixed berries

Berry Swirl

A marbled dance of strawberry and blueberry compote through creamy cheesecake batter — bright, tangy, and beautifully balanced.

Rich chocolate cheesecake with chocolate crumb crust

Double Chocolate

For those who don't take dessert lightly. Cocoa-infused batter, a chocolate cookie crust, and a ganache finish that changes everything.

Salted caramel cheesecake with drizzle topping

Salted Caramel

Sweet meets savory in every bite. Homemade caramel swirled into a silky base, finished with a delicate flaky sea salt crunch.

Lemon cheesecake with citrus glaze and zest

Lemon Cream

Crisp, sunny, and refreshingly tart — a lemon cheesecake that cuts through richness with a bright citrus glaze and a graham crust.

Seasonal specialty cheesecake with decorative topping

Seasonal Specials

Rotating flavors that celebrate the season — from pumpkin spice to holiday peppermint. Ask about what's currently baking.

Cheesecake being prepared in a home kitchen
Freshly sliced cheesecake ready for serving
Polk City Proudly Made Here
Our Story

A Passion Baked Into Every Slice

Cheesecakes by Alexis LLC started with a simple belief: that the best cheesecakes aren't mass-produced — they're made with intention, patience, and real ingredients. Located in the heart of Polk City, Iowa, we handcraft each cheesecake to order, ensuring that every order receives the same careful attention to detail that we'd give our own families.

From selecting the finest cream cheese to baking each cake low and slow for that signature creamy texture, nothing is rushed. We believe that when you take the time to do something right, the result speaks for itself.

Baked to Order Never pre-made. Always fresh.
Premium Ingredients No shortcuts, ever.
Custom Orders Size, flavor, and design — your way.
How It Works

From Our Oven to Your Table in Three Simple Steps

Ordering a handcrafted cheesecake shouldn't be complicated. We've made the process as smooth as our filling.

01

Choose Your Flavor

Browse our rotating selection of classic and seasonal flavors, or tell us about a custom creation you have in mind.

02

Place Your Order

Reach out by phone or email with your flavor choice, size, and pickup date. We'll confirm everything before baking begins.

03

Pick Up & Enjoy

Collect your freshly baked cheesecake and enjoy the moment. Every slice is crafted to deliver exactly what you were hoping for.

What People Say

Loved by Our Neighbors in Polk City and Beyond

"The best cheesecake I've had in the Des Moines area, hands down. Dense, creamy, and the crust was perfect. Will definitely be ordering again for every gathering."

M
Local Customer

"Ordered a custom cheesecake for a birthday and it exceeded every expectation. The attention to detail was obvious from the first bite. Thank you, Alexis!"

S
Local Customer

"I've tried many cheesecakes over the years, and this one stands out. You can tell it's made with real care and quality ingredients. A true local gem."

J
Local Customer
Ready to Taste the Difference?

Your Next Favorite Cheesecake Is One Call Away

Whether it's a birthday, a holiday gathering, or simply because you deserve it — order a handcrafted cheesecake that makes the moment memorable.

Call 515-423-9688 Send a Message
Get in Touch

Let's Make Your Next Occasion Special

Have a question about flavors, sizes, or custom orders? We'd love to hear from you. Reach out by phone, email, or stop by — we're right here in Polk City.

Address 208 W Grimes St
Polk City, IA 50226-2114
Message sent! We'll get back to you shortly.
Is this your business?This is my business